DAF vs Private Foundation and the Third Option Most People Miss

You want to give meaningfully, but choosing the right structure can feel overwhelming. Set up a private foundation, and you're running a small organization. Open a Donor-Advised Fund, and you're limited to writing checks. Or what if you want something in between?

This article breaks down two familiar structures: the Donor-Advised Fund and the private foundation, and introduces a third approach that most people miss: fiscal sponsorship (we'll walk through it from the lens of Givinga Foundation's Charitable Foundation Account (CFA)).

Note: This is educational information, not legal or tax advice. Your circumstances matter, and you should talk with your tax and legal advisors before choosing a structure.

‍

What is a Donor Advised Fund (DAF)?

A DAF is a charitable account sponsored by a 501(c)(3) public charity (often a community foundation or a national financial institution) that gives account holders the ability to manage tax liabilities, grow their giving assets, and give flexibly. Contributed assets receive a charitable deduction in the year of contribution, returns on contributed assets grow tax-free, and grants to eligible nonprofits are made at the account holder's discretion over time.

Why DAFs are so popular

• Quick setup: Often set up quickly with minimal friction.
• Reporting and administration: The sponsor handles receipting, due diligence, grant processing, and reporting.
• Tax advantages: Generally, more favorable deduction treatment than private foundations (varies by asset type and donor situation).
• Timing: No required 5% annual payout at the account level (as commonly structured).
• Privacy: Account holders control all information provided to charitable organizations and all individual account activity is "rolled up" into the sponsoring organization's 990 reporting.

The key limitation

A DAF is built for grantmaking to existing qualified 501(c)(3) public charities and is highly restricted against other activities such as paying vendors, hiring staff, executing programs, or operating campaigns from the account.

When a DAF makes the most sense

A DAF shines when you want the cleanest, simplest structure to support 501(c)(3) public nonprofits you trust, especially if you value ease, tax planning flexibility, and privacy.

Givinga Foundation's Charitable Investment Account (CIA) is our modern DAF offering for individuals who want a more intentional, modern approach:

• contribute flexibly (including appreciated assets),
• take an immediate deduction when it matters,
• grow assets tax-free, and
• grant with transparent reporting and privacy

‍

What is a private foundation?

A private foundation is a standalone charitable entity (typically a 501(c)(3)) funded and controlled by an individual, family, or corporation. It can make grants to nonprofits and, in many cases, run its own charitable programs.

What it's great for

• Control and identity: Clear mission, board governance, a named vehicle, long-term strategy. Full control of investment decisions.
• Legacy-building: A structure designed to persist over time (often multi-generational).
• Range of activity: Grantmaking plus the potential to operate programs (with compliance requirements).

The trade-offs to take seriously

• Time and complexity to set up: New entity formation, governance, IRS process, policies
• Ongoing administration: Accounting, compliance, board meetings, recordkeeping, annual filings
• Required annual minimum distribution: Private foundations generally must meet a 5% annual payout requirement
• More public visibility: Key financial and operational details are disclosed in public filings
• Cost: Legal, accounting, tax prep, and potential staffing/outsourcing — often meaningful over time
• Limited number of funding sources (often one family or corporation) and stricter regulatory requirements
• Less favorable deduction limits for cash, appreciated assets, and securities

When a foundation makes the most sense

A foundation tends to fit when you're prepared to commit substantial time, oversight and assets, want full control, and are willing to operate (or fund) the infrastructure that comes with running a charitable organization.

‍

What is a Charitable Foundation Account (CFA)?

Givinga Foundation's Charitable Foundation Account (CFA) is a bridge between a donor-advised fund and a private foundation. The CFA uses a fiscal sponsorship structure and gives Account Holders a named, tax-deductible foundation-like charitable account under Givinga Foundation's established 501(c)(3) public charity (the fiscal sponsor).

The CFA incorporates the structure and credibility of a private foundation, while operating under a public charity, with a more flexible giving structure than a DAF.

What makes a CFA different

• A CFA is designed to support charitable activity beyond writing grants, such as running programs, campaigns, events, and paying approved charitable expenses under sponsor oversight.
• You get a visible philanthropic identity: More "initiative-forward" than a typical DAF.
• You avoid forming a new nonprofit: No separate entity to maintain, no standalone annual filings in your name like a private foundation.
• All administrative, IRS reporting, 990 filings and oversight requirements are performed by the Givinga Foundation, saving CFA holders time and expense while protecting them from IRS or regulatory scrutiny.

What you gain

• Speed and flexibility: Launch a structured initiative in days, without months of entity setup
• Favorable public charity tax treatment: Contributions are generally treated as gifts to a public charity
• Operational support: Sponsor handles compliance, accounting, receipts, and guardrails
• Fundraising-friendly: Often easier to invite outside donors into a public charity structure than into a private foundation or a typical personal DAF use case

The trade-offs

• Sponsor oversight is real: The sponsor is ultimately responsible for compliance and must approve how funds are used.
• Fees are typically higher than a DAF because the sponsor is doing more than processing grants (exact fees depend on services and structure). Givinga Foundation has one of the lowest fee structures in the industry.

When a CFA makes the most sense

A CFA is often a strong fit when you want a branded philanthropic initiative with the ability to be hands-on, but you don't want to take on the costs, overhead, and public disclosure that come with running a private foundation.

‍

Key differences at a glance

A practical "best fit" summary

• Choose a private foundation if you want maximum autonomy, maximum legacy, and you're ready to operate (or staff) the engine behind it.
• Choose a DAF if you want a simple, tax-efficient grantmaking vehicle with low overhead and strong privacy.
• Choose a CFA if you want a foundation-like platform without forming and maintaining a standalone foundation entity.

Learn More

If you're exploring a foundation alternative that still feels credible, structured, and "official," it may be worth taking a closer look at Givinga Foundation's Charitable Foundation Account. Givinga Foundation's CFA is built for donors who want that middle path: a compliant, flexible platform for meaningful giving, without turning philanthropy into an administrative job.

And if your goal is simpler: plan your giving, donate appreciated assets, let funds grow tax-free, and grant when you're ready, Givinga Foundation's Charitable Investment Account (CIA) is our modern Donor-Advised Fund designed for individuals who want their generosity to be organized, intentional, and easy to manage over time.